A Battle Between Two Landmarks : Penn Station and Madison Square Garden: Contrasting Legacies

Abstract

In this paper we will delve into the ongoing debate between Pennsylvania Station and Madison Square Garden, shedding light on the tragic demolition of the old Penn Station and the subsequent creation of a new landmark. Today, Penn Station is underground, with the Garden resting on top. These two iconic structures have a long history of conflict, each striving to maintain its relevance and presence. The Station stands as one of the most bustling transportation hubs, uniting individuals from various cities in one central location. Simultaneously, the Garden occupies the upper space, thriving as a renowned entertainment venue that hosts prestigious events. Yet, considering its celebrated architectural magnificence, there is a pervasive curiosity regarding the removal of the old Penn Station. This curiosity leads to an exploration of the former Penn Station's influence on New York City and, consequently, how the Garden stands as a structure that played a role in the demise of the old Station.